EDIT 20/01/2016: I just found another critique and case-study by Natalia Fernández on what I’m currently calling “sharewashing”.

yes-the-planet-got-destroyed-but

This cartoon by Tom Toro originally appeared in the New Yorker

I just added a bunch of crowdfunding sites to the Disintermedia blogroll, and created a new category; freelancing, which currently has entries for BountySource and Gun.io. As I did, I started to wonder, and not for the first time, what do I really know about all these projects and organisations? Do I really want to endorse them all, and if I do, how do I decide which ones? Underlying these questions is another question: how can I tell the difference between genuinely revolutionary libre commons projects, based on “crowdsourcing” and “pay it forward” principles, and their corporate dopplegangers, which are more like “outsourcing” and “pay it upwards”?

AirBnB and BookaBach are classic examples. They clothes themselves in the aura of couchsurfing social networks (the term is much older than the website of the same name) like the Hospitality Club, and BeWelcome (forked in protest by CouchSurfing volunteers and users when CS changed their legal structure from non-profit to for-profit). These community-driven networks are about letting a friend you haven’t met yet stay on your couch or in your spare room for free, “pay it forward” style. When you, or a friend or family member, needs somewhere to stay, your reputation as a good host can help you find one. Even with the restructured CouchSurfing, no money changes hands for hosting. The sites are social enterprises, existing to serve the community, not make money, and cover their relatively minimal operating costs through donations, and optional premium services like reputation endorsements.

Hostel owners might carp about lost revenue from unpaid couchsurfing, as they do about “freedom camping” in campervans and house buses (sounding a lot like the record industry complaining about gratis file-sharing), but it’s just as likely the budget traveller couldn’t afford their rates anyway, and would otherwise just have to cut their trip short. Ironically, in their early days, hostel federations like YHA (Youth Hostel Association, now known as Hostelling International), along with schemes like WWOOF (Willing Workers on Organic Farms), were set up to make independent travel more accessible to young people - the same reason as couchsurfing platforms. Hostels and WWOOF farms offered an affordable alternative to hotels in the cities, and bed-and-breakfasts in rural areas.

AirBnB and BookaBach, by contrast, are for-profit companies, which rather than crowdsourcing new social goods outside the market economy (eg a free place to sleep and a new friend), compete underhandedly against existing hospitality businesses. Unlike the couchsurfing networks, the accommodation options offered by their online booking platform cost money, and they take a cut of each transaction, but their operating costs too are minimal. Unlike the local accommodation businesses they compete with for the same revenue, they can do business anywhere, and they don’t have to provide any guarantee of quality, cover any maintenance costs, pay hospitality staff or comply with any of the public regulations that cover the hospitality industry.

This issue was brought into sharp relief by Yochai Benker in  ‘The Idea of the Commons and the Future of Capitalism‘, the talk he gave at the Global CreativeCommons Summit 2015. Benkler, a Harvard Law Processor who wrote ‘The Wealth of Networks‘ and ‘The Penguin and the Leviathan‘ and coined the phrase “commons-based peer-production”, has been a champion of genuine commons projects like the GNU+Linux operating system and Wikipedia:

  • public goods that anyone (with internet access) can use.
  • created collaboratively by people as either volunteers in their free time, or as part of regular, paid employment.
  • facilitated by community leaders whose influence is directly proportionate to their contribution and reputation.
  • under the stewardship of consensus-driven organisational structures; ground-breaking, horizontally structured not-for-profit foundations, or sometimes cooperative companies jointly owned by their customers, their worker, or both.

But he pulls no punches in his criticism of companies like Uber, AirBnB, and Amazon’s Mechanical Turk, which are able to use their passing resemblance to genuine “commons economy” models - mainly the use of websites and mobile “apps” to organise workers and customers - to camouflage typical corporate psychopathy:

  •  private goods, behind a paywall that pushes revenue up to the top of the company, with only a small fraction “trickling down” to the people doing the work that earns the revenue.
  • outsourcing the workforce of the taxi industry, turning secure rental accommodation into budget hotel rooms, and replacing secure jobs, with guaranteed minimum wages and working conditions, with casualized, “alienated labour” in “digital sweatshops”.
  • facilitated by a combination of automated bureaucracy (the “apps” and the servers that power them) and human bureaucrats, whose influence is proportionate to their salary, title, and position in a corporate hierarchy.
  •  under the stewardship of traditional, for-profit, private companies, or shareholder corporations

Disturbingly, there are commentators who fudge these two totally opposed models together, using projects and companies from both ends of the spectrum as examples of the “sharing economy“. Examples include ‘Collaborative Consumption‘ author Rachael Botsman, Jason Tanz of WIRED, and LinkedIn founder Reid Hoffman. Tim O’Reilly - “open source software” propagandist and commercial publisher of software manuals under ARR (All Rights Reserved) copyright - has even organised a “Next: economy” conference (starting tomorrow in San Fransisco), with keynote speakers including the heads of Uber, Lyft,  and GE, as well as Microsoft, who are legendary for ruthlessly slandering the real commons, in the form of GNU+Linux, with decades of “FUD” (Fear, Uncertainty, and Doubt). This isn’t just the old free market economy in drag. O’Reilly seems determined to hijack the emerging global conversation around the political-economic implications of the commons economy, in defence of non-partisan corporatism, as he did with previous buzzphrases like “open source” (originally “free software”), “web 2.0″ (originally “open publishing”, “citizen journalism”, and “social media”), “democracy 2.0″ (”privatization” and “outsourcing” of government services) and “the cloud” (a truly meaningless blend of “virtual servers”, “APIs” for plugging into major websites like FaceBook, and “Service as a Software Substitute“).

When people are bedazzled by this style of silicon valley glamour, and don’t distinguish between the gift economy of the “collaborative commons” (Jeremy Rifkin’s term) and the “micro-tasking” sweatshops of the “sharing economy”, these companies can dodge the social norms, expected standards, and public regulations, which normally protect both paid workers and paying customers from exploitation. This allows shareholders to redirect massive pools of money out of the real economy and into buying more shares and financial derivatives, and fuelling speculation bubbles, while the local businesses that workers used to be able to keep going in their own communities by spending their earnings, shed staff and eventually close.

Kimberley Bryant of Black Girls Code, also speaking at “Next: Economy”, is either incredibly brave or supremely naive to be going into that nest of vipers. While project like Black Girls Code are about preparing people from marginalized groups for jobs, the rest of the speakers are busy abolishing them.

Filed November 11th, 2015 under open source

Thanks to organisers Enspiral, Michel Bauwens of the P2P Foundation and Commons Transition is coming out to Aotearoa, in late November 2015, to speak about ‘P2P Design, Open Source Collaboration, & the Sharing Economy’. Michel will give six talks, in five cities, covering both Te Wai Pounamu, and Te Ika a Maui. Full tour details, including flyers that can be downloaded and printed out, are available on the Enspiral website.

Filed November 6th, 2015 under free culture, Makers, free software, News
  • Annual Events

  • Digital Freedom Foundation
  • LibrePlanet
  • Aotearoa

  • Aotearoa Indymedia
  • BallaNZ
  • Creative Commons Aotearoa/ NZ
  • Creative Freedom Foundation
  • DigitalNZ
  • Enspiral
  • Fair Deal Coalition
  • GreenStage
  • InternetNZ
  • Island Bay World Service
  • Living Economies
  • Localise
  • Loomio
  • Matrix FM
  • Nicky Hagar
  • No Right Turn
  • NZ Council for Civil Liberties
  • NZ Makers
  • NZ Makers Map
  • NZ Māori Internet Society
  • NZ Open Source Awards
  • NZCommons
  • OASIS
  • Open Government Ninjas of NZ
  • Open Source Society of NZ
  • Open Standards NZ
  • Open Ur Eyes
  • Pacific Media Centre
  • Permaculture in NZ
  • PledgeMe
  • Radio Chomsky
  • Regulation
  • Scoop
  • Tech Liberty
  • Timebank Aotearoa
  • Transition Towns Aotearoa/ NZ
  • Uncensored Magazine
  • Waatea News
  • Waikato Linux Users Group
  • What If
  • Wiki NZ
  • Zenbu
  • archives

  • ArchiveTeam
  • Critical Commons
  • Ibiblio
  • Internet Archive Community Software Collection
  • Open Archives Initiative
  • Blogroll

  • Abject
  • Access Now
  • Ars Technica
  • Autonomo.us
  • BadScience
  • Banjo - RoboBlog
  • Boing Boing
  • Born out of Binary
  • Centre for Media and Democracy
  • Choke Point Project
  • Copyrighteous
  • Create Digital Music
  • Creative Commons International
  • Cryptogon
  • Digital Standards Organisations
  • Disinfo
  • E-Democracy
  • Electronic Privacy Information Center
  • Ever Vigilant
  • Freedom Box Foundation
  • Freedom of the Press Foundation
  • Gaming On Linux
  • Global Indymedia
  • Gondwanaland (Mike Linksvayer)
  • Institute for the Future of the Book
  • Institute of Network Cultures
  • Internet Governance Project
  • InternetNZ
  • Island Bay World Service
  • Iterating Towards Openness
  • Knowledge Ecology International
  • LinkedListCorruption
  • Linuxed - Exploring Linux Distros
  • Localise
  • Moved by Freedom - Powered By Standards
  • Nanowares
  • New Zealand Māori Internet Society
  • Nicky Hagar
  • No Right Turn
  • NZ Council for Civil Liberties
  • NZCommons
  • O'Reilly Radar
  • OASIS
  • OERu Technology Blog
  • Open Educational Resources Foundation
  • Open Knowledge Foundation
  • Open Rights Group
  • Open Social Web
  • Open Source Conscious Intelligence Network
  • Open Source Food
  • Open Stand
  • Open Ur Eyes
  • OpenCollective
  • OpenDotDotDot
  • OpenSource.com
  • Permaculture in NZ
  • Plumi
  • Public Interest Journalism Foundation
  • Punk Rock Permaculture
  • Question Copyright
  • Replicant (OS)
  • Rob Meyers
  • Schneier on Security
  • Scoop
  • Shareable
  • Slashdot
  • Software Freedom Law Centre
  • Software in the Public Interest
  • SourceMap
  • Sustento Institute
  • Tech Liberty
  • TechRights
  • The Tin Hat
  • Tinkering Down Under
  • TorrentFreak
  • TransitionMovement
  • Translation Project
  • Trisquel GNU/ Linux
  • United Diversity
  • Waatea News
  • We Speak for Freedom
  • Why Your Boss is Programmed To Be a Dictator
  • code bank

  • Allura
  • BitBucket
  • FusionForge
  • GITHub
  • GITLab
  • Gogs
  • Internet Archive Community Software Collection
  • LaunchPad
  • NotABug
  • Savannah
  • Software Freedom Conservancy
  • Software Heritage
  • Sourceforge
  • community economics

  • Commons Transition
  • Fruit Tree Planting Foundation
  • In Our Back Yards
  • Institute for Local Self-Reliance
  • Libre-Living
  • Living Economies
  • Sensorica
  • Sustainable Economy Law Centre
  • Timebank Aotearoa
  • TransitionMovement
  • cooperative

  • Loomio
  • Snowdrift Coop
  • crowdfunding

  • ArtistShare
  • BountySource
  • Causes
  • CauseVox
  • Crowdfunder
  • Crowdjustice
  • Crowdrise
  • Crowdsupply
  • Flattr
  • Fundit.buzz
  • GiveaLittle
  • Goteo
  • In Our Back Yards
  • KickStarter
  • KissKissBankBank
  • Liberapay
  • Mighty Cause
  • OpenGift
  • Patreon
  • PledgeMe
  • PledgeMusic
  • Pozible
  • Snowdrift Coop
  • StartSomeGood
  • Taproot Foundation
  • The Working World
  • Tidelift
  • Events

  • IndieWebCamp
  • free code

  • April
  • Black Duck Open Hub
  • DistroWatch
  • Ever Vigilant
  • F-Droid
  • Free Software Directory (GNU FDL 1.3 or later)
  • Free Software Support Network
  • Free Software Support Network
  • Free Your Android
  • FreshCode
  • Gogs
  • Gun.io
  • Internet Archive Community Software Collection
  • LILA
  • LinuxTracker
  • NotABug
  • OERu Technology Blog
  • Peers Community
  • Plumi
  • PublicLab
  • Replicant (OS)
  • Software Heritage
  • Urchn Studios
  • Free Media

  • Communes Collective
  • Copyrighteous
  • Create Digital Music
  • Definition of Free Cultural Works
  • Dyne Foundation
  • FLOSSManuals
  • Free Culture Foundation
  • Ibiblio
  • Librivox
  • LILA
  • Open Video Conference
  • Show Me Do
  • Translation Project
  • Urchn Studios
  • WikiLeaks
  • freelancing

  • BountySource
  • Gun.io
  • independent media

  • Aotearoa Indymedia
  • BallaNZ
  • EngageMedia
  • Freedom of the Press Foundation
  • LILA
  • Matrix FM
  • Pacific Media Centre
  • Public Interest Journalism Foundation
  • Radio Chomsky
  • Radio Heritage Foundation
  • Uncensored Magazine
  • Waatea News
  • libre gaming

  • Gaming On Linux
  • Makers

  • GreenStage
  • Libre-Living
  • Mediamatic
  • NZ Makers
  • NZ Makers Map
  • Open ROV
  • Renewable PCs
  • Rob Meyers
  • Sensorica
  • maps

  • GeoForAll
  • GeoNames
  • Green Map System
  • Map Tools
  • Open Geospatial Foundation
  • Open Street Map
  • open governance

  • Crowdfunding
  • D-Cent
  • Deep Democracy Institute International
  • E-Democracy
  • Fight for the Future
  • Holacracy
  • Internet Governance Project
  • Kettering Foundation
  • Knowledge Sharing Toolkit (CC-BY-SA 3.0)
  • Open Government Ninjas of NZ
  • Open Policy Network
  • Open Space World (CC-BY-SA 2.5)
  • Open Stand
  • Open Standards NZ
  • Participedia
  • Sunlight Foundation
  • Transition Towns Aotearoa/ NZ
  • What If
  • WikiLeaks
  • open hardware

  • H-Node
  • Makey Makey
  • Meeblip Open Source Bass Synth
  • Open Hardware Summit
  • Open ROV
  • Open Source Hardware Association
  • Orgs

  • Access Now
  • Apache Foundation
  • April
  • Autistici/Inventati
  • Collaborative Knowledge Foundation
  • Commons Transition
  • Communes Collective
  • Computer Professionals for Social Responsibility
  • Creative Commons Aotearoa/ NZ
  • Creative Freedom Foundation
  • Critical Commons
  • D-Cent
  • Deep Democracy Institute International
  • Digital Due Process coalition
  • Digital Freedom Foundation
  • Digital Standards Organisations
  • DigitalNZ
  • Dyne Foundation
  • E-Democracy
  • Electronic Frontiers Foundation
  • Electronic Privacy Information Center
  • Fair Tracing Project
  • Fight for the Future
  • Foundation for Peer-to-Peer Alternatives
  • Free Culture Foundation
  • Free Network Foundation
  • Free Software Foundation
  • Free Software Support Network
  • Free Software Support Network
  • Freedom of the Press Foundation
  • Guifi
  • Ibiblio
  • Identity Commons
  • Institute for Local Self-Reliance
  • Internet Engineering Taskforce
  • Internet Governance Project
  • ISA Commons
  • Kettering Foundation
  • LEAP Encryption Access Project
  • LILA
  • Living Economies
  • Loomio
  • May First/ People Link
  • Mediamatic
  • NZ Māori Internet Society
  • NZ Open Source Awards
  • Open Architecture Network
  • Open Archives Initiative
  • Open Geospatial Foundation
  • Open Policy Network
  • Open Source Hardware Association
  • Open Source Society of NZ
  • Open Web Foundation
  • OpenADR Alliance
  • OpenCorporates
  • OpenHatch
  • Participatory Culture Foundation
  • Peers Community
  • Permaculture in NZ
  • Privacy International
  • Public Citizen
  • Public Interest Journalism Foundation
  • Public Knowledge
  • Public Patent Foundation
  • Question Copyright
  • Radio Heritage Foundation
  • ReDecentralize
  • Reform Government Surveillance
  • Regulation
  • Rhizome
  • RiseUp
  • Science Commons
  • Software Carpentry Foundation
  • Software Freedom Conservancy
  • Sunlight Foundation
  • Sustainable Economy Law Centre
  • Taproot Foundation
  • Transition Towns Aotearoa/ NZ
  • Waikato Linux Users Group
  • Wiki NZ
  • World Wide Web Consortium (WC3)
  • Xiph.org
  • XMPP Standards Foundation
  • Peer2Peer

  • BitCoin
  • FreeCoin
  • Permaculture

  • Appropedia (CC-BY-SA 3.0)
  • Fruit Tree Planting Foundation
  • Future Scenarios
  • OrganicDesign
  • Permaculture in NZ
  • TransitionMovement
  • We Speak for Freedom
  • Privacy

  • Access Now
  • Digital Due Process coalition
  • Ever Vigilant
  • Fight for the Future
  • International Principles on the Application of Human Rights to Communications Surveillance
  • LEAP Encryption Access Project
  • OASIS
  • Privacy International
  • Reform Government Surveillance
  • What If
  • protocols and licensing

  • Definition of Free Cultural Works
  • Digital Standards Organisations
  • Greenlots
  • ISA Commons
  • Open Archives Initiative
  • Open Stand
  • Open Standards NZ
  • Open Web Foundation
  • OpenADR Alliance
  • Regular Events

  • Libre Graphics Meeting
  • Open Hardware Summit
  • science and datasets

  • AllTrials
  • Collaborative Knowledge Foundation
  • DigitalNZ
  • Fair Tracing Project
  • ISA Commons
  • Open Geospatial Foundation
  • Open Hand Project
  • SourceMap
  • Wiki NZ
  • Zooniverse
  • Tools

  • Autistici/Inventati
  • BitCoin
  • Black Duck Open Hub
  • CoActivate
  • Crowdfunding
  • DistroWatch
  • Dyne Foundation
  • F-Droid
  • FLOSSManuals
  • Fork the Cookbook
  • FreeCoin
  • GITHub
  • GNU Operating System
  • GreenStage
  • H-Node
  • How To Escape the GoogleMax Panopticon
  • Knowledge Sharing Toolkit (CC-BY-SA 3.0)
  • LEAP Encryption Access Project
  • LinuxTracker
  • Loomio
  • Map Tools
  • May First/ People Link
  • Meeblip Open Source Bass Synth
  • Monolith
  • Open Hand Project
  • Open Source Ecology
  • Open Space World (CC-BY-SA 2.5)
  • Open Street Map
  • OpenCorporates
  • OpenMailBox
  • Participatory Culture Foundation
  • Plumi
  • Renewable PCs
  • Replicant (OS)
  • RiseUp
  • Savannah
  • Show Me Do
  • Sourceforge
  • SourceMap
  • TransforMap
  • Translation Project
  • Web Platform
  • Zenbu
  • Transition

  • Green Map System
  • Health After Oil
  • Localise
  • OrganicDesign
  • Wiki

  • Appropedia (CC-BY-SA 3.0)
  • Foundation for Peer-to-Peer Alternatives
  • Instructables
  • LibrePlanet
  • Open (Government) NZ
  • Participedia
  • SourceWatch
  • WikiEducator
  • wireless mesh

  • Guifi
  • workplace democracy

  • Enspiral
  • The Working World